Showing posts with label Yucca Mountain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yucca Mountain. Show all posts

09 June 2008

NV: More Knee Jerking Over Yucca

“The United States Department of Energy submitted its license application for the proposed Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository to the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission on June 3,” wrote Nevada Attorney General Catherine Cortez-Masto in an op/ed in this Sunday's Nevada Appeal. “Nevada's experts reviewed the application and quickly concluded that it is neither viable nor complete.”

I'm wondering who these “Nevada experts” were. I think I'll call the AG's office this week and ask. If there's one thing I've learned in my short stint on NV's political airwaves, it's that big words get bandied around like nobody's business and follow-up questions are key. (Shall we take a wild guess and speculate that at least some of these "experts" are people who have already come down against Yucca in the past? And shall we ask how they managed to sift through the 8,600 page application in less than a week in order to render their "expert" verdict...? The Nuclear Regulatory Commission is expected to take three to four years to evaluate all the information before reaching its decision on whether or not to license the Repository...so who were these speed-reading geniuses that managed to do it in 4 days?)

We keep seeing what looks an awful lot like co-ordinated knee-jerk opposition over Yucca Mountain lately. Stand by!

07 June 2008

Yucca Licensing Application Is In

The Reno Gazette Journal reports that Reid and Ensign blast the latest push to get the repository at Yucca Mountain approved. No surprise there. And, since the licensing approval process will take at least another 3 years, this issue will soon be sleeping again. Is no one in Nevada going to get ready for the likelihood that the site will be approved? Don't we have some lobbying and negotiating to do to ensure Nevada benefits from this decision? At least one man is trying, see here.

28 May 2008

What Floats McCain's Boat

Chuck Muth’s YuccaFacts has good fun today. He first quotes John McCain on Yucca Mountain in a speech in Denver yesterday:

“I would seek to establish an international repository for spent nuclear fuel that could collect and safely store materials overseas that might otherwise be reprocessed to acquire bomb-grade materials. It is even possible that such an international center could make it unnecessary to open the proposed spent nuclear fuel storage facility at Yucca Mountain in Nevada.”

Muth then reminds us that a primary argument of Yucca Repository opponents has been Transportation and quips, Does the term “mobile Chernobyl” ring any bells?” Now, enter McCain with this grand Plan for overseas storage. Muth poses the obvious question: “How is it going to get there?” and wonders how consistent opposers will be in re: to their objections when the destination is no longer Yucca – nor indeed, anywhere in the good old U.S. of A.

My questions are: Which lucky nation does McCain have in mind for the storage site? Who will enthusiastically raise their hand in favor of becoming the world’s nuclear septic tank? And how does Mr. GreenJeans – the guy who now sells organic t-shirts and mugs on his website and “uncategorically opposes” building an oil refinery and pipeline in rural Alaska so a few caribou can freely enjoy an unfettered sunset – justify suggesting floating boatloads of radioactive waste in and out of the world’s major ports and population centers?

16 May 2008

Center for Yucca Facts Cites Heritage Foundation Report : Yucca Mountain Remains Critical to Spent Nuclear Fuel Management

See this Yucca Facts blog post for the Heritage Foundation's report on the role of Yucca Mountain in the future of nuclear power in the U.S. While acknowledging that Yucca is not the whole answer, Heritage says it IS part of the solution - if not held up by politics, and if properly managed.

15 May 2008

Reader Question re: Yucca Mountain Nuclear Power Plant: "wouldn't the plant's cooling water be radioactive?"

I don't know much about the inner workings of nuclear power plant cooling systems, so I started with a patent search and found U.S. Patent 4894202. It is a "method of inhibiting radioactive substances from eluting into cooling water in a nuclear plant and an apparatus" issued on January 16, 1990. One would assume that a patented method/product that's been in existence for 18 years is in use, but I will continue to research this - and anyone who passes this way should feel free to Comment with what they know or learn.

26 April 2008

Chuck Muth: The Yucca Mountain Gold Mine

After my post re: the Bob Loux letter re: his objections to the DOE's plans for Yucca, the always lucid Chuck Muth emailed me the link to this post on his new Yucca Facts blog. In it he presents the many possible Pros for a nuclear waste repository. Although I still think the DOE's Not-Yet-Invented Supercalifrajalistic Robots are pretty funny, Chuck makes many excellent observations. (Let's call them Muthservations for purposes of this discussion.)

The first Muthservation is that the great state of NV currently has a variety of problems: a budget shortfall, water shortages, high energy costs, road construction needs, and a lack of quality higher education opportunities. (Agreed. Actually, as Muth points out, these are all Facts so agreement is quite beside the point. Therefore, I withdraw it and just nod knowingly.) The next Muthservation (as recently reported in the Lousville Courier-Journal) is that uranium is now selling for around $73 a pound and that We-Have-The-Technology to extract it from "worthless" nuclear waste, so the uranium that could be recovered from the "waste" would be worth $7.6 billion. (wow!) Muth suggests that if Nevada became the site for our Great Nation's nuclear reprocessing center as well as the storage site for all the waste, Nevadan's could/would benefit in the form of a major budget surplus, plus a lot of highly skilled high-paying jobs, not to mention lots of cheap electricity from the plant (me Like-ee).

Chuck further Muthservates (that is the verb form) that some of the surplus money could be used to build a water pipeline from the Pacific to Yucca Mountain, where the power from the Nuclear Power Plant could be used to desalinate the ocean water (again, We-Have-The-Technology, given the ability to generate enough heat, which a nuclear reactor could do and then some) and solve all our water shortage problems. (This is freaking brilliant, so why is this the first time I've heard about this idea? Am I That out of touch with the talking points in favor of Yucca? If so, shame on me. I'll take comfort in the fact that I'm not alone because a small straw poll of Nevada residents (i.e. a few friends and family members) revealed that no one else had heard of this being a viable idea either.)

Finally, as a result of the nuclear "waste" repository (I shall never again think of it as waste), Muth says that with the reprocessing and uranium extraction center, the power plant, and the desalinization facility, we'd then have every reason to establish a Yucca Mountain Nuclear Technology University, complete with (and this may be my favorite Muthservation of all): an NCAA basketball team. (Muth suggests we name them the "Fighting Neutrons." With respect, I think we can do better with the Name-ology and shall proceed to think of ideas.) Oh yes, one more thing. All of this would likely lead to the necessity for a four-lane super highway connecting Yucca Mountain with Las Vegas and Reno (wouldn't THAT be nice), plus enough extra money to build enough roads to solve all our other gridlock problems.

Note/Update: a Yucca Facts reader, Bruce Jackson, pointed out that another benefit could be a major hydrogen production station/distribution system making Nevada a world leader in motor vehicles (and other power-using things) that use hydrogen fuel cell technology. Many believe this is the future of New Energy (and that bio-fuels are not, which now also seems to be the consensus of the entire world in light of recent food shortages/rising food prices).

21 April 2008

DOE's Brilliant Plan for Managing Nuclear Waste at Nevada's Yucca Mountain Includes Not-Yet-Invented Robots

In a recent Yucca Mountain story, reporter Keith Rogers at the Las Vegas Review Journal wrote that “a Department of Energy plan to install thousands of titanium alloy drip shields in the distant future to keep water from corroding nuclear waste canisters inside Yucca Mountain has failed to convince Nevada officials that a repository, if built there, would be safe.” Apparently the executive director of Nevada’s Nuclear Projects Agency, Bob Loux, has written a three-page letter to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission explaining the inadequacy of the plan. Rogers said Loux's letter claimed that installing expensive drip shields a century from now (to protect the waste cannisters from corrosion) probably won't be possible because the DOE's plans rely on using robots that (a) have yet to be invented and (b) will need to be able to install the 5-ton shields by remote control in hot, highly radioactive rock-strewn tunnels. Additionally, Loux said that the amount of titanium needed for the 11,500 drip shields "would consume about a third to half of the world's current annual titanium production" and that the "availability of such quantities of this material...is not something anyone can assure with any confidence.”

Not sure Loux needed to cite concerns with future titanium quantities after pointing out that the DOE "plan" called for giant not-yet-invented heat-resistant anti-radioactive remote-control robots smart and agile enough to carefully install 10,000-pound drip shields over each of Yucca's underground waste cannisters. (You can't make this stuff up, folks!)
 
Clicky Web Analytics